> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://magentadebrief.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Training accidents look the same with or without an instructor
- URL: https://magentadebrief.com/atsb-instructional-flying-occurrences/
- Published: 2026-11-16T02:40:06.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-16T02:40:06.000Z
- Description: The ATSB counted a decade of training accidents. An instructor on board did not change their shape, and the recovery decided the outcome.
- Author: Alan Soon
- Tags: Briefs, Safety, Training, Australia

The ATSB has published [a decade of instructional flying occurrences](https://www.atsb.gov.au/publications/research-and-analysis-report/2026/aviation/instructional-flying-occurrences-2015-2024?ref=magentadebrief.com), covering 2015 to 2024\. It counted 187 accidents across 5,131 occurrences — 15 fatal, 9 causing serious injury. About 19 accidents a year, with the rate falling across the decade.

**The right seat changes nothing about the accident**  

Dual and solo flying produced almost the same number of accidents. The shape of them matches: aircraft control issues in just under two-thirds of each, terrain collisions in over half of each. Ten of the dual accidents were fatal, against five of the solo ones. What the counts establish is that an instructor on board did not produce a different kind of accident.

**The recovery is the whole difference**  

Of the accidents that involved loss of control, exactly one was recovered. In serious incidents, recovery was achieved in about two in five, which puts the weight on [training the recovery itself](https://magentadebrief.com/are-we-teaching-avoidance-instead-of-flying/).

The ATSB’s list of recurring safety factors names monitoring and checking, with one illustration: “instructor not acting to recover the aircraft in sufficient time”. At [Orange in 2018](https://www.atsb.gov.au/investigations/ao-2018-038?ref=magentadebrief.com), on the owner's first night training flight in a Cirrus SR22, the instructor did not take control during the go-around. She was used to talking him through control problems and did not see that he had become disoriented. Both were seriously injured and the aircraft was destroyed.

**Before your next dual flight**  

Ask what is new in the flight, and ask to see it flown before you are directed through it. The ATSB’s safety message from Orange is that a pilot meeting a new sequence or environment should see it demonstrated first. The instructor went straight to directing, and then spent the go-around repeatedly telling a disoriented pilot to level the wings.